02 February, 2011

Benihana Kuwait and Justice

I have been meaning to post here for days. Sorry it's late, but you never know - there might be someone out there who's missed this. I thought I'd just document the whole Benihana Kuwait goof up.

Arguably the most popular Kuwaiti blog, 2:48AM, put up a post last December which talked about dining at the newly opened Benihana restaurant there. It wasn't a glowing review, objective enough but deeply disappointed with the quality of the food and the lack of spectacle, apparently a major part of the Benihana experience.

The post attracted a slew of astroturf, identified as such in comments by 2:48AM blogger Mark, and then a venomous little comment from a chap purporting to be the GM of the franchise holder which threatened to sue the blog. It also made some odd comments about elephants but that, as they say, is another story.

Mark received the law suit on January 30th. I caught his shocked tweet and retweeted it, then nipped off to post about the whole affair - as eny fule no, this is something of a landmark as it's the first time a company has sued a blogger in the Middle East (do please correct me if I'm wrong) - we could all really do without this sort of thing. Obviously, suing the most popular blog in Kuwait is not something most communications professionals would counsel, let alone as an opening gambit..

The news spread quickly, with a lot of very unhappy people leaving comments on Benihana Kuwait's Facebook page. Opinion was 100% behind Mark and angry towards Benihana Kuwait for taking this action. There was not one dissenting voice - everyone agreed that Benihana Kuwait had been arrogant, stupid and misguided in filing suit against a customer expressing an opinion. It was a rollicking read, but eventually Benihana Kuwait did what any craven, arrogant sod would do and deleted the whole wall. Twitter had quite a bit of fun around the #BenihanaKUW hashtag, particularly with the antics of @BenihanaGPR, the 'global PR' joke account that was eventually suspended (presumably it had been reported as spam).

Some tried contacting Benihana Kuwait, one person got through to GM Mike Servo and was rewarded with a subsequent threatening phone call. Mark asked that people not try to telephone Benihana as it may prejudice his case.

Blogs were a-posting across the region, from the UAE to Lebanon (Egypt has obviously had rather bigger fish to fry) as people heard of the story. By the afternoon, the UAE newspapers had picked up the story, the next day saw it featuring in the Kipp Report as well as Arabian Business. We also featured it on the DubaiToday radio show yesterday and brought Mark on to talk about how being sued for a blog post made him feel. (The audio link is over at FPS if you want to listen in to how it went) And then The Next Web, Slashdot and BoingBoing. The Benihana Wikipedia page was updated with the usual speed to include the fact that Benihana Kuwait had sued a blogger. This has been edited out by Wikipedia contributor Donald Albury because it cited blogs and they're not a reliable source. Odd. Googling Benihana would have got him the mainstream media references. Oh well...

By this time, Google was showing the blogs and other media reporting the story as every entry bar one in the first page of search for "Benihana Kuwait" and the story was on the first page of search for "Benihana". Mark posted up a list of media that have covered this and it's here.

A statement, first shared when it was sent to Ghassan Deeb (@gabdallah), was posted on the Benihana Inc Facebook page distancing the company from the growing furore. Benihana Inc operates restaurants in America - it's actually a separate company, Benihana Tokyo, that's responsible for the international franchise business, and so for Kuwait. That statement has now, in a priceless escalation of a situation that was always utterly avoidable, been shared with the world's media via PR Newswire:

"Benihana Inc. (Nasdaq: BNHNA; BNHN) has recently become aware of a lawsuit allegedly filed by Benihana against a blogger in Kuwait for his unfavorable review of a local BENIHANA restaurant. Benihana Inc. wishes to correct the misinformation being disseminated on the Internet and published in articles connecting Benihana Inc. to this lawsuit, when it is not."


This will doubtless have a great many journalists around the world asking 'what lawsuit?'. It's the latest in a series of almost wilfully insane mis-steps by the company at every level - and, by the way, the 'Internet' has not been disseminating 'misinformation' - to consumers, a Benihana is a Benihana.


As of this morning, there was also a 'Boycott Benihana Kuwait' Facebook page - the inevitable reaction to deleting unhappy comments on your own Facebook page. It's linked here.



The charge sheet, then:


  • Astroturfing a blog.
  • A company officer leaving a long, rambling, angry, incoherent and threating comment on a blog.
  • Filing suit rather than attempting to have a discourse. 
  • Filing suit against the most popular blog in the country.
  • Suing a customer who had a bad experience in your restaurant and dared to say so.
  • Ignoring aggrieved consumers on your Facebook page.
  • Deleting customer comments on your Facebook page.
  • Failing to respond quickly to a growing crisis caused by one of your franchisees.
  • Responding poorly and escalating the issue with an unhelpful news release.
  • Silence from both the franchisee and franchise owner in the face of thousands of concerned consumers.

The damage to the Benihana brand can only be imagined. And it's not over yet. If you haven't already, I would ask that you leave a comment on the Benihana Tokyo website asking them to pressure Benihana Kuwait into dropping this awful lawsuit - which seeks damages at a minimum of KD 5001 (About Dhs60k!). Links and stuff are over here at the Fake Plastic blog.


Cheers!

23 comments:

Autocrat said...

This is absurdity is exactly the reason I no longer live in the middle-east.

rosh said...

WOW, that's just bad sushi.

Seabee said...

Going off on a tangent from what we've been on about Alex, I wonder whether Benihana Tokyo think the Kuwait franchisee is meeting their standards of food and entertainment...

From Beirut - Mohamed's Blogs said...

You should add discrimination to the charge list.

Susan said...

Amused at the Facebook page - all these fake IDs saying how wonderful it is. How stupid do they think we are?

mohammed said...

very bad

Dubai Photo Story said...

I did write to Benihana of Tokyo but not response yet. It's been about a week now.

By the way, did you notice that the GM's name (in the comments section of Mark's blog) links back to the Benihana website. Not the one of Benihana of Tokyo.

Dubai Photo Story said...

Apparently there is a T-Shirt out in the Kuwait market with the slogan "I went to Benihana for dinner and I all I got was a lousy lawsuit"

:-)

Anonymous said...

This post is great.

A Scot writing about an overpriced Japanese foodie joint in Kuwait on the UAE Community Blog with opinions thrown in by different nationalities on this board.

Now, that is what I call globalization.

Faisal Haji said...

I don't think an opinion should ever be retreated or sued. An opinion is a personal statement and should always be respected. Instead of suing, I would take that post and hang it in the Customer Care office to improve the services.

-----

@Autocrat: the west are the inventors of suing, many and many times do you hear people getting fired for comments on blogs, facebook and twitter. So please don't blame the middle east for everything wrong in this world.

a question of a question said...

Must have been difficult to decide on which topic to blog. This or the happenings in Egypt.

Mathew said...

I'm really outraged and have no idea where to vent, so am doing so here with the hope that bloggers can take this up:

As per today's Khaleej Times, the bus company allegedly involved in the rape of a 4 year old child at Dubai Modern High School got an award from Dubai's Deputy Ruler for and I quote from the paper:

"School Transport Services LLC — for its initiative in the provision of safe mobility for students and teachers."

Safe mobility - I kid you not...See the link:

http://www.khaleejtimes.com/displayarticle.asp?xfile=data/theuae/2011/February/theuae_February267.xml&section=theuae&col=

Outrageous! Can we get STS to give this award back pending the end of the investigation?

Sally - My Custard Pie said...

I received an auto-response from Benihana Tokyo but have heard nothing (although promised) since. This lot should go and work for a bank!

chefandsteward.com said...

We have been following this case for several reasons. We are in F&B, Journalism and Communication fields and it is interesting where the freedom of expression is aligned in the region. It is fine to say glowing remarks but where negative, it is evident that silence is deemed best. The outcome of this case will have repercussions not just for bloggers but for journalists in the region and beyond. From a PR perspective, I am certain their PR department is wishing they never took on that job!

alexander... said...

Take a look at the #BenihanaKUW hashtag. Amazing.

Mich said...

Pity my blog (Mich Cafe) was dropped on the Community. But all can go to the #BenihanaKUW hashtag on Twitter and see the noise we have made today. Hopefully it will help Mark :-)

Lirun said...

off the topic.. but i wanted to drop a ray of light of how we view a certain situation by providing this link http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/sports/tennis-peer-i-m-under-more-pressure-1.343628 :)

Lirun said...

and - did anyone see whats going on in baharain?

Autocrat said...

@Faisal Haji

In the West we have protection of free speech. In the GCC there is no speech that is free unless the sheikh agrees with it.

The blogger in question does not work for Benihana. Even if he did, his right to express his own opinion would have been protected in a civilized country.

I guess the persian gulf countries just dont like anything with 'free' in it like free speech, free trade, free market. However monopolization and market manipulation are strongly encouraged.

Lirun said...

does anyone care out here?? can you really all ignore what is going on in the rest of the middle east?? hang on.. in the gulf region as well???

wake up people.. provide a voice.. the rest of the content here is close to meaningless..

what point is there blogging about freedom of speech if you dont even use it for anything meaningful

hemlock said...

@ lirun: does anyone care out here?? can you really all ignore what is going on in the rest of the middle east?? hang on.. in the gulf region as well???

ROFL... please tell me you at least recognize the irony in your comment.

Unjane said...

@Lirun - I guess they are all afraid to comment. Or just not interested. I believe it could just as easily be the one as the other. *sigh*

Kyle said...

Lirun:

This is the UAE Community Blog where the majority of posters & commentators are expat residents that are here for the work.

Now to answer your question about lending a voice or support to whatever's transpiring in the neighboring region, that doesn't concern expats in any way. Moreover, and here I speak only for myself. If I had a voice to raise, I'd raise it back home where it'd be heard, reasoned, debated and corrective measure(s), if any, would be taken in due course. However, I wish I could say the same about anywhere else though.

Hence, try and just be and wait for this Community (thanks to SD, Samuraisam and all the Admin Gang) to come back to life. After all, we've all invested heavily in it via our posts and the outpouring of outbursts amongst the intelligent debates.

Take care & stay in touch :)

Post a Comment

NOTE: By making a post/comment on this blog you agree that you are solely responsible for its content and that you are up to date on the laws of the country you are posting from and that your post/comment abides by them.

To read the rules click here

If you would like to post content on this blog click here